HKS vs. ARK
10-08-2011, 12:54 PM
#16
but the real question is, stock ipl vs hks on ipl gains? I no they will be minimal, but is it worth the $$$
10-08-2011, 12:57 PM
#17
10-08-2011, 01:22 PM
#19
That is true . The both have horrible welds . Ark forgot to weld some spots and the hks was just terrible. If you open up a hks you will see the h pipe is not cut right to maximize air flow . It's isn't even cut evenly on both sides . The hks sounds like rice and the can exhaust tips is very dated .. The ark sounds great have fix their fitment issues and they continue to make it better . It's evolving as we speak. Having owned both I would pic the ark hands down ...
This ^ -- has NOT been my experience. Not saying' NBS did not have this experience, jus sayin' I didn't. If an exhaust system can be beautiful, the HKS system I bought certainly was, right out of the box.
"sounds like rice" -- that comment does have me scratching my head a bit -- to each his own I guess. [No offense NBS]
Keep researching and buy what you like. The frustrating thing is there is no substitution for seeing and hearing a system in person but its hard to find set ups matching your car to look at in person.
FWIW,
Sco1oter
10-08-2011, 01:59 PM
#20
OP:
This ^ -- has NOT been my experience. Not saying' NBS did not have this experience, jus sayin' I didn't. If an exhaust system can be beautiful, the HKS system I bought certainly was, right out of the box.
"sounds like rice" -- that comment does have me scratching my head a bit -- to each his own I guess. [No offense NBS]
Keep researching and buy what you like. The frustrating thing is there is no substitution for seeing and hearing a system in person but its hard to find set ups matching your car to look at in person.
FWIW,
Sco1oter
This ^ -- has NOT been my experience. Not saying' NBS did not have this experience, jus sayin' I didn't. If an exhaust system can be beautiful, the HKS system I bought certainly was, right out of the box.
"sounds like rice" -- that comment does have me scratching my head a bit -- to each his own I guess. [No offense NBS]
Keep researching and buy what you like. The frustrating thing is there is no substitution for seeing and hearing a system in person but its hard to find set ups matching your car to look at in person.
FWIW,
Sco1oter
Sound is subjective. Someone might like the sound of ARK. Another might like the sound of HKS. I've heard the ARK sound referred to as resembling that of a "kazoo." Here we see HKS and "rice" in the same sentence. It's a matter of personal opinion.
Like Sco1oter said, do your research. ARK has been around for a few years. Their design is a copy of the HKS design. Their parts are manufactured in Korea. Are they "evolving as we speak"? That's up for debate. What is not up for debate is that HKS has been a leader in the Japanese automotive performance industry for almost 40 years with multiple records and championships under their belt. They have their own R&D facility. Simply, I would suggest that there is a reason that HKS is one of the most knocked-off automotive aftermarket parts companies out there.
10-08-2011, 02:28 PM
#21
Here's my honest opinion..
I have HKS for more than 2 years now and if I can pick HKS or ARK all over again, I'd still pick HKS. Btw ARK wasn't out yet when I bought the exhaust...
Because from my experience (what I saw in real life),
1) ARK burnt tips turn brown/bronze over time, in less than a year. Color looks like crap. My HKS burnt tips still looks brand new like Day-One.
2) ARK does not sit balanced on both sides when you look at it from behind. This is a major turn off for me. I know some people did point out HKS also sit a little imbalanced.. but as far as I know I can't tell. And cmon.. it's not as bad as ARK which is crazy obvious.
However, ARK sounds so much better than HKS. It's louder, it's throatier, it's deeper. But I just can't stand having an exhaust on my car that looks like crap.
I have HKS for more than 2 years now and if I can pick HKS or ARK all over again, I'd still pick HKS. Btw ARK wasn't out yet when I bought the exhaust...
Because from my experience (what I saw in real life),
1) ARK burnt tips turn brown/bronze over time, in less than a year. Color looks like crap. My HKS burnt tips still looks brand new like Day-One.
2) ARK does not sit balanced on both sides when you look at it from behind. This is a major turn off for me. I know some people did point out HKS also sit a little imbalanced.. but as far as I know I can't tell. And cmon.. it's not as bad as ARK which is crazy obvious.
However, ARK sounds so much better than HKS. It's louder, it's throatier, it's deeper. But I just can't stand having an exhaust on my car that looks like crap.
10-08-2011, 05:23 PM
#23
Administrator
I say ditch both and go Fast Intentions!
10-08-2011, 05:57 PM
#24
That is true . The both have horrible welds . Ark forgot to weld some spots and the hks was just terrible. If you open up a hks you will see the h pipe is not cut right to maximize air flow . It's isn't even cut evenly on both sides . The hks sounds like rice and the can exhaust tips is very dated .. The ark sounds great have fix their fitment issues and they continue to make it better . It's evolving as we speak. Having owned both I would pic the ark hands down ...
Not always, my FI exhaust sounded awesome with my BERK HFCs but when I switched to MXP it sounded like crap because the MXP piping was thinner than FI. I put the stock cats back in and problem was solved for me.
10-08-2011, 06:37 PM
#25
I saw that picture too where some guy cut apart his HKS and found that the H-pipe correctly, but is there any way to verify that was an authentic HKS product? I personally don't believe that picture.
Not always, my FI exhaust sounded awesome with my BERK HFCs but when I switched to MXP it sounded like crap because the MXP piping was thinner than FI. I put the stock cats back in and problem was solved for me.
Not always, my FI exhaust sounded awesome with my BERK HFCs but when I switched to MXP it sounded like crap because the MXP piping was thinner than FI. I put the stock cats back in and problem was solved for me.
10-08-2011, 11:09 PM
#26
OP:
This ^ -- has NOT been my experience. Not saying' NBS did not have this experience, jus sayin' I didn't. If an exhaust system can be beautiful, the HKS system I bought certainly was, right out of the box.
"sounds like rice" -- that comment does have me scratching my head a bit -- to each his own I guess. [No offense NBS]
Keep researching and buy what you like. The frustrating thing is there is no substitution for seeing and hearing a system in person but its hard to find set ups matching your car to look at in person.
FWIW,
Sco1oter
This ^ -- has NOT been my experience. Not saying' NBS did not have this experience, jus sayin' I didn't. If an exhaust system can be beautiful, the HKS system I bought certainly was, right out of the box.
"sounds like rice" -- that comment does have me scratching my head a bit -- to each his own I guess. [No offense NBS]
Keep researching and buy what you like. The frustrating thing is there is no substitution for seeing and hearing a system in person but its hard to find set ups matching your car to look at in person.
FWIW,
Sco1oter
I was relating my explanation to your experience, because I was following your thread since day one up until you posted all the pics. +1.
10-08-2011, 11:11 PM
#27
Here's my honest opinion..
I have HKS for more than 2 years now and if I can pick HKS or ARK all over again, I'd still pick HKS. Btw ARK wasn't out yet when I bought the exhaust...
Because from my experience (what I saw in real life),
1) ARK burnt tips turn brown/bronze over time, in less than a year. Color looks like crap. My HKS burnt tips still looks brand new like Day-One.
2) ARK does not sit balanced on both sides when you look at it from behind. This is a major turn off for me. I know some people did point out HKS also sit a little imbalanced.. but as far as I know I can't tell. And cmon.. it's not as bad as ARK which is crazy obvious.
However, ARK sounds so much better than HKS. It's louder, it's throatier, it's deeper. But I just can't stand having an exhaust on my car that looks like crap.
I have HKS for more than 2 years now and if I can pick HKS or ARK all over again, I'd still pick HKS. Btw ARK wasn't out yet when I bought the exhaust...
Because from my experience (what I saw in real life),
1) ARK burnt tips turn brown/bronze over time, in less than a year. Color looks like crap. My HKS burnt tips still looks brand new like Day-One.
2) ARK does not sit balanced on both sides when you look at it from behind. This is a major turn off for me. I know some people did point out HKS also sit a little imbalanced.. but as far as I know I can't tell. And cmon.. it's not as bad as ARK which is crazy obvious.
However, ARK sounds so much better than HKS. It's louder, it's throatier, it's deeper. But I just can't stand having an exhaust on my car that looks like crap.
My opinion exactly. Ark wins on sound, and looses everywhere else. HKS looses on sound, but wins everywhere else. Especially the part with the tips. Plus, HKS does not drone. I've asked quite a few people who have it, and they all said "no drone."
10-09-2011, 12:11 AM
#29
Yeap, if you were looking for a similar looking exhaust, it would be HKS or FI. You can't go wrong with either of them. I was debating FI and HKS when I was shopping for mine. It was a tough choice..
Other notable exhausts would be Greddy and MXP. Though MXP wasn't out yet at the time I bought my exhaust.
Other notable exhausts would be Greddy and MXP. Though MXP wasn't out yet at the time I bought my exhaust.
10-09-2011, 12:35 AM
#30
Yeap, if you were looking for a similar looking exhaust, it would be HKS or FI. You can't go wrong with either of them. I was debating FI and HKS when I was shopping for mine. It was a tough choice..
Other notable exhausts would be Greddy and MXP. Though MXP wasn't out yet at the time I bought my exhaust.
Other notable exhausts would be Greddy and MXP. Though MXP wasn't out yet at the time I bought my exhaust.
I chose FI for its amazing sound, and also for the best customer service ever from Tony. Ark is the second best-sounding, in my opinion. Then Meisterschaft.