Why no AWD manual transmission?
#1
Registered User
Thread Starter
Why no AWD manual transmission?
Just curious. Seems to be a trend amongst most manufacturers (except Subaru and maybe Audi).
And even worse if you are looking for a diesel.
I lived in Belgium for 2 years. While I don't miss much, I do miss the diesels, MT's, fries, beer, and chocolate. Waffles too sometimes.
I love my 6MT Sedan (that I am selling if anybody wants to buy), but if I could have gotten the 6MT with AWD up here in the great white north, I would have (although with real snowtires, not the performance ones, it's ok....real problem with it is the tire width and amount of power to the rear wheels, hard to downsize them with the big brakes)
And even worse if you are looking for a diesel.
I lived in Belgium for 2 years. While I don't miss much, I do miss the diesels, MT's, fries, beer, and chocolate. Waffles too sometimes.
I love my 6MT Sedan (that I am selling if anybody wants to buy), but if I could have gotten the 6MT with AWD up here in the great white north, I would have (although with real snowtires, not the performance ones, it's ok....real problem with it is the tire width and amount of power to the rear wheels, hard to downsize them with the big brakes)
#3
Registered User
Thread Starter
The Juke is another offender. And the CX-5. Not that I've been looking around at these vehicles.
Also disappointing about most current manuals is the shorter gearing and worse efficiency than automagics.
*sigh*
Maybe I'll just have to keep my G
Also disappointing about most current manuals is the shorter gearing and worse efficiency than automagics.
*sigh*
Maybe I'll just have to keep my G
#4
Administrator
iTrader: (9)
I briefly considered the A4 2.0T 6MT before deciding on the G, but after driving the car, I have to say... the car was stupidly boring. A floaty, detached feedback from the suspension, a weak clutch, and an unresponsive throttle. It's a salesman's car, not a driver's car. For that, you have to step up to the S4. But that carries with it an unacceptable (and indefensible) price tag.
You keep saying you want to sell your car, but I think you'd be hard-pressed to find something equivalent that satisfies both your values and your pocketbook.
#5
Registered User
iTrader: (2)
Most companies are starting to trend away from manual transmissions. Look at the GTR, Nissans premier sports car, it only comes in auto manual with tiptronic. Ferrari doesn't even offer a manual transmission anymore. Lamborghini has also been steering away from the manual transmission.
#6
Most companies are starting to trend away from manual transmissions. Look at the GTR, Nissans premier sports car, it only comes in auto manual with tiptronic. Ferrari doesn't even offer a manual transmission anymore. Lamborghini has also been steering away from the manual transmission.
#7
Trending Topics
#8
Registered User
Thread Starter
You keep saying you want to sell your car, but I think you'd be hard-pressed to find something equivalent that satisfies both your values and your pocketbook.
If I can talk her out of an SUV and into a wagon/hatch, then the G is probably safe. What gets me tho, is that once you start adding options to a mazda3 hatch (or mazdaspeed3), or a WRX, you are encroaching, if not outright entering, G territory. And then we're talking not as much power, same efficiency, questionable interior comforts.
#9
Administrator
iTrader: (9)
While this is largely true, the other half can't drive stick very well, the G isn't the best car for her to learn on, and there's no way she could ever drive this in the winter. Life's full of these compromises. She wants a little SUV with a sunroof. I'm trying to find something that won't make me want to kill myself when we go on road trips together, like her Cobalt makes me want to do.
If I can talk her out of an SUV and into a wagon/hatch, then the G is probably safe. What gets me tho, is that once you start adding options to a mazda3 hatch (or mazdaspeed3), or a WRX, you are encroaching, if not outright entering, G territory. And then we're talking not as much power, same efficiency, questionable interior comforts.
If I can talk her out of an SUV and into a wagon/hatch, then the G is probably safe. What gets me tho, is that once you start adding options to a mazda3 hatch (or mazdaspeed3), or a WRX, you are encroaching, if not outright entering, G territory. And then we're talking not as much power, same efficiency, questionable interior comforts.
And really, how difficult would it be to drive a 6MT Tiguan? (Not very)
#10
Registered User
Thread Starter
I generally harbor a lot of ill-will for VW/Audi.
That was a vehicle I hadn't considered. Might be worth a look. Certainly can't hurt to take a test drive. Maybe grind a few gears. (edit: according to VW website, Tiguan only AWD for auto tranny)
I'm not completely opposed to an automatic. I'm more wondering why AWD+MT don't go together. While market forces may dictate this as JDDSSC121 alludes to, it doesn't seem to bother subaru.
That was a vehicle I hadn't considered. Might be worth a look. Certainly can't hurt to take a test drive. Maybe grind a few gears. (edit: according to VW website, Tiguan only AWD for auto tranny)
I'm not completely opposed to an automatic. I'm more wondering why AWD+MT don't go together. While market forces may dictate this as JDDSSC121 alludes to, it doesn't seem to bother subaru.
#11
Administrator
iTrader: (9)
#12
Registered User
iTrader: (9)
also, the AWD transmission would need to be re-engineered for the application. R&D and related costs may not balance based on the limited prospective demand.
of course, to gearheads like us it doesn't make any sense! a disproportionate number of us would love the 6MT/AWD configuration.
Last edited by canucklehead; 04-27-2012 at 04:17 PM.
#13
Registered User
Thread Starter
This is very very true. Also, I think for Subaru you could say it is an outlier. I don't think subaru has been making much 2WD stuff since the Loyale.
Also, meant to comment on Audi. While they do offer 6MT all over their lineup...they are generally incredibly front heavy vehicles that I wouldn't dare ever own out of warranty (that warranty bit applies to VW as well)
Also, meant to comment on Audi. While they do offer 6MT all over their lineup...they are generally incredibly front heavy vehicles that I wouldn't dare ever own out of warranty (that warranty bit applies to VW as well)
Last edited by owslystnly; 04-27-2012 at 02:50 PM. Reason: forgot about audi
#14
Administrator
iTrader: (9)
Everyone has different values in a car. Personally, I love where the G-Sedan 6MT measures up. Perfect car for me right now.
#15
Registered User