G37S 6MT shifter stick vibration?
10-10-2007, 12:59 PM
#46
My Grand Boss just got rid of his 545i due to continuous problems which had his car in the shop more than in his hands. The e46 M3s seem to have been built fairly well. Apart from the occasional engine blowing up, they have been reliable as far as I know. However, their build quality is not *amazing* -- my friend's e46 m3 convertible is a bucket of rattles and squeaks (most noisy car I've *ever* ridden in) and it is only five years old. I'll take my vibrating shifter and quiet, well assembled interior =)
Having a lot of electronics on a car is no excuse for it having problems, Infinitis and Lexuses (Lexi?) have plenty of electronics on them and generally do not experience issues.
Having a lot of electronics on a car is no excuse for it having problems, Infinitis and Lexuses (Lexi?) have plenty of electronics on them and generally do not experience issues.
10-10-2007, 05:55 PM
#47
Registered User
Join Date: Sep 2007
Posts: 8
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Toyotas, Hondas and to a lesser degree Nissans should be reliable, well-engineered cars; an issue like this is something I might expect from say Chrysler. While they won't match high-end German cars in numerous aspects, I would expect them to be superior in terms of quality control and reliability. So I'd have to agree with the respondent who mentioned the issues with German cars. I also don't disagree with the person who noted the reliability of the Porsche and BMW he has in his family, but 2-3 years is not a real great test - I'd be really disappointed to run into problems after such a short amount of time. It's 5-6 years and over 100 K miles that differences in durability and reliability should really show up. On a 3 year lease, a BMW should be fine, but I'm really nervous about buying one.
10-10-2007, 06:26 PM
#48
Toyotas, Hondas and to a lesser degree Nissans should be reliable, well-engineered cars; an issue like this is something I might expect from say Chrysler. While they won't match high-end German cars in numerous aspects, I would expect them to be superior in terms of quality control and reliability. So I'd have to agree with the respondent who mentioned the issues with German cars. I also don't disagree with the person who noted the reliability of the Porsche and BMW he has in his family, but 2-3 years is not a real great test - I'd be really disappointed to run into problems after such a short amount of time. It's 5-6 years and over 100 K miles that differences in durability and reliability should really show up. On a 3 year lease, a BMW should be fine, but I'm really nervous about buying one.
10-10-2007, 08:04 PM
#51
From what I know only Nissan and Infinity have this problem, and i do admit my 2004 350z had this problem
10-10-2007, 09:01 PM
#52
[QUOTE=carlo_amacio;2230469]My 2006 SI doesnt have it. My dads 2007 S2000 doesnt have it. My neighbors RSX-S and my Co-workers IS300 doesnt have it. Basically what im saying is your generalizing and Im pretty sure you havent driven ALL of the japanese cars out there From what I know only Nissan and Infinity have this problem, and i do admit my 2004 350z had this problem[/QU
first off i didnt say all japanese cars have this problem. I said all the japanese cars I had had this problem. Its funny the cars you mention my neighboor has a 2007 Si and the first thing he complained about was how much his shifter vibrated, my dads paralegal has a 06 rsx non S and her's does the same thing also. She had me look at it because she thought there was something wrong with it. And one of my guys at my shop has an 03 is300 and his did the same thing also until we installed a sequential shifter. As far as the 07 S2000 i cant say anything because i have not driven one nor had one at my shop yet. But my 02 did it and every year up to 06 i have driven and they have all done the same thing.
From what I know only Nissan and Infinity have this problem, and i do admit my 2004 350z had this problem[/QUfirst off i didnt say all japanese cars have this problem. I said all the japanese cars I had had this problem. Its funny the cars you mention my neighboor has a 2007 Si and the first thing he complained about was how much his shifter vibrated, my dads paralegal has a 06 rsx non S and her's does the same thing also. She had me look at it because she thought there was something wrong with it. And one of my guys at my shop has an 03 is300 and his did the same thing also until we installed a sequential shifter. As far as the 07 S2000 i cant say anything because i have not driven one nor had one at my shop yet. But my 02 did it and every year up to 06 i have driven and they have all done the same thing.
10-10-2007, 09:53 PM
#53
Registered User
Join Date: Jan 2006
Posts: 547
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
[QUOTE=UNV-IT46;2230483]
WTF a Civic Si with a vibrating shifter? That's a cable shift FWD transmission. What's making the shifter vibrate? Same goes for the RSX.
Inlines run smoother than V's. If the shifter is mechanical linkage, it will vibrate in sync with the engine. This should hold true for all front engine/rear-drive cars. The VQ is especially rougher than your typical inline in terms of idle. This is what makes most of your BMWs and your S2000s have less vibrating shifters.
IMO, Heavy duty transmission + rougher engine + direct linkage stick = vibrating stick
My 2006 SI doesnt have it. My dads 2007 S2000 doesnt have it. My neighbors RSX-S and my Co-workers IS300 doesnt have it. Basically what im saying is your generalizing and Im pretty sure you havent driven ALL of the japanese cars out there From what I know only Nissan and Infinity have this problem, and i do admit my 2004 350z had this problem[/QU
first off i didnt say all japanese cars have this problem. I said all the japanese cars I had had this problem. Its funny the cars you mention my neighboor has a 2007 Si and the first thing he complained about was how much his shifter vibrated, my dads paralegal has a 06 rsx non S and her's does the same thing also. She had me look at it because she thought there was something wrong with it. And one of my guys at my shop has an 03 is300 and his did the same thing also until we installed a sequential shifter. As far as the 07 S2000 i cant say anything because i have not driven one nor had one at my shop yet. But my 02 did it and every year up to 06 i have driven and they have all done the same thing.
From what I know only Nissan and Infinity have this problem, and i do admit my 2004 350z had this problem[/QUfirst off i didnt say all japanese cars have this problem. I said all the japanese cars I had had this problem. Its funny the cars you mention my neighboor has a 2007 Si and the first thing he complained about was how much his shifter vibrated, my dads paralegal has a 06 rsx non S and her's does the same thing also. She had me look at it because she thought there was something wrong with it. And one of my guys at my shop has an 03 is300 and his did the same thing also until we installed a sequential shifter. As far as the 07 S2000 i cant say anything because i have not driven one nor had one at my shop yet. But my 02 did it and every year up to 06 i have driven and they have all done the same thing.
WTF a Civic Si with a vibrating shifter? That's a cable shift FWD transmission. What's making the shifter vibrate? Same goes for the RSX.
Inlines run smoother than V's. If the shifter is mechanical linkage, it will vibrate in sync with the engine. This should hold true for all front engine/rear-drive cars. The VQ is especially rougher than your typical inline in terms of idle. This is what makes most of your BMWs and your S2000s have less vibrating shifters.
IMO, Heavy duty transmission + rougher engine + direct linkage stick = vibrating stick
10-10-2007, 11:09 PM
#54
10-10-2007, 11:13 PM
#55
its real easy to cut one sentence out of my whole post and say oh oh look you meant this... why not post the whole post. here i will save you time and do it for you
"was the one who stated about the porsche and bmw. i dont have experience over 3 years on any of those cars because i have leased all my cars for 3 years. But i can state that I have had more problems with my honda S2000, 350z, and Evo over three years then i have had with both BMW's i have had over three years. i cant say anything about the infiniti as i have not had that three years. but if my nissan was anything to judge by i would say i should expect problems. Also all the japanese cars had the same shifter vibration issues as the g37...."
Once again i never said ALL JAPANESE CARS HAVE THIS ISSUE... If you know how to read its pretty clear i was talking about the cars in my post which i have owned....
"was the one who stated about the porsche and bmw. i dont have experience over 3 years on any of those cars because i have leased all my cars for 3 years. But i can state that I have had more problems with my honda S2000, 350z, and Evo over three years then i have had with both BMW's i have had over three years. i cant say anything about the infiniti as i have not had that three years. but if my nissan was anything to judge by i would say i should expect problems. Also all the japanese cars had the same shifter vibration issues as the g37...."
Once again i never said ALL JAPANESE CARS HAVE THIS ISSUE... If you know how to read its pretty clear i was talking about the cars in my post which i have owned....
10-19-2007, 04:44 PM
#57
Hey guys, I don't know about the rest of you but I have reached 1700 miles on my G37S 6MT. I had a lot of vibrations in the first few hundred miles and as time and miles built up, the vibration has seem to go away more and more. Just the other day I was at a light in neutral and I could have sworn that I thought the car was off. My shifter was still. I
I think with the improved shifter for the 08s, the vibrations will minimize as the miles+engine+transmission breaks-in.
I think with the improved shifter for the 08s, the vibrations will minimize as the miles+engine+transmission breaks-in.
10-19-2007, 04:49 PM
#58
Registered User
Join Date: Jan 2006
Posts: 547
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
I think most of it is you getting used to it.
Some of it might be engine running smoother. I think it is what it is -- the shifter is hard connected to the engine via the tranny.. it will shake if the engine is shaking and not shake if the engine is not shaking. That will vary day-to-day, car-by-car.
Some of it might be engine running smoother. I think it is what it is -- the shifter is hard connected to the engine via the tranny.. it will shake if the engine is shaking and not shake if the engine is not shaking. That will vary day-to-day, car-by-car.
10-19-2007, 05:04 PM
#59
I think most of it is you getting used to it.
Some of it might be engine running smoother. I think it is what it is -- the shifter is hard connected to the engine via the tranny.. it will shake if the engine is shaking and not shake if the engine is not shaking. That will vary day-to-day, car-by-car.
Some of it might be engine running smoother. I think it is what it is -- the shifter is hard connected to the engine via the tranny.. it will shake if the engine is shaking and not shake if the engine is not shaking. That will vary day-to-day, car-by-car.
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
superjoey
D.I.Y. Installations/Modifications
31
03-22-2023 11:56 PM
