Michelin HydroEdge vs Goodyear Assurance TripleTred
#1
Michelin HydroEdge vs Goodyear Assurance TripleTred
Last Saturday I initiated a 39 month lease on a 2010 G37x which came with the Dunlop SP SportMaxx tires. I live in the mountains of North Carolina and we get snow/ice (this year an unusual 7 feet of snow since Dec 5th!). I thought those tires might be ok for the winter, but I read somewhere where they're not intended for snow. While I hate the idea of replacing brand new tires, I guess I should think about replacing them and getting more appropriate tires. The two choices I've come up with are either the Michelin HydroEdge or Goodyear Assurance TripleTred. I don't want a winter set and a summer set of tires. I want one set of tires that are all weather.
My assumption is that either tire would be an ok choice. But I thought maybe some of you may have input on which one would be a better tire, especially for wet and snow traction.
Also, when I go through the motions for purchase on a website, it recommends a TPMS Rebuild Kit. Is this necessary since the car is brand new? Can they use the ones that are already there?
I've also seen on the boards where I'll then have to do something at the dealer (Infiniti...or can Nissan do it??) regarding re-registration of the TPMS. Didn't realize this until today either.
Also, not sure what I'd do with the Dunlop's, maybe sell them?? Wish someplace would give me a credit toward my new tire purchase if I gave them the Dunlops. I would also assume that the Michelin and Goodyear tires (90,000 and 80,000 treadlife, respectively) would still be in fine shape at the end of my 39 month lease and I'd turn the car in with them on. I'm not a hard core driver, don't squeal the tires or do burnouts.
Any thoughts are greatly appreciated.
My assumption is that either tire would be an ok choice. But I thought maybe some of you may have input on which one would be a better tire, especially for wet and snow traction.
Also, when I go through the motions for purchase on a website, it recommends a TPMS Rebuild Kit. Is this necessary since the car is brand new? Can they use the ones that are already there?
I've also seen on the boards where I'll then have to do something at the dealer (Infiniti...or can Nissan do it??) regarding re-registration of the TPMS. Didn't realize this until today either.
Also, not sure what I'd do with the Dunlop's, maybe sell them?? Wish someplace would give me a credit toward my new tire purchase if I gave them the Dunlops. I would also assume that the Michelin and Goodyear tires (90,000 and 80,000 treadlife, respectively) would still be in fine shape at the end of my 39 month lease and I'd turn the car in with them on. I'm not a hard core driver, don't squeal the tires or do burnouts.
Any thoughts are greatly appreciated.
Last edited by jdljr; 02-25-2010 at 08:10 PM.
#2
Registered User
iTrader: (1)
Join Date: Apr 2009
Location: Toronto, Ontario, Canada
Posts: 95
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
Living in Canada... From my experience is: Snow tire is the only way to go. What you can do is to get another set of wheels (something smaller maybe 17s) and use 17inch snows. Just use you oem 18s with Dunlaps in the summer. The tire pressure light might be annoying in the winter but it does cost a lot to buy another set. just check your tire pressure regularly.
#4
Registered User
Tire & Wheel Noob here:
Would 17-inch rims for snow tires fit on the G37s sedan? I seem to recall reading somewhere the brakes were a bit larger on the sport. Also, what is the complete size of the tires that would go on 17s? Would it still need to be staggered?
Thanks
Would 17-inch rims for snow tires fit on the G37s sedan? I seem to recall reading somewhere the brakes were a bit larger on the sport. Also, what is the complete size of the tires that would go on 17s? Would it still need to be staggered?
Thanks
#5
Registered User
iTrader: (1)
Join Date: Apr 2009
Location: Toronto, Ontario, Canada
Posts: 95
Likes: 0
Received 0 Likes
on
0 Posts
If the car comes with the big 4 piston calipers with the 14inch disc ( same as the ones on the c37s coupe and has "infiniti" written on them) Then you will need to run at least 18 inch wheels. Also, If u want to get aftermarket wheels you will need to be really careful about the caliper clearance. So to answer your question: If u have the S with the big brakes the best is to get OEM size snow tires and mount and the oem wheels. It does not matter it is not stagger or not as long as it fits properly. IF u dont have big calipers, then you run 17 inchs with offset in the mid to high 40s and 225/55/17 snow tires.
#6
Registered User
iTrader: (1)
Last Saturday I initiated a 39 month lease on a 2010 G37x which came with the Dunlop SP SportMaxx tires. I live in the mountains of North Carolina and we get snow/ice (this year an unusual 7 feet of snow since Dec 5th!). I thought those tires might be ok for the winter, but I read somewhere where they're not intended for snow. While I hate the idea of replacing brand new tires, I guess I should think about replacing them and getting more appropriate tires. The two choices I've come up with are either the Michelin HydroEdge or Goodyear Assurance TripleTred. I don't want a winter set and a summer set of tires. I want one set of tires that are all weather.
My assumption is that either tire would be an ok choice. But I thought maybe some of you may have input on which one would be a better tire, especially for wet and snow traction.
Also, when I go through the motions for purchase on a website, it recommends a TPMS Rebuild Kit. Is this necessary since the car is brand new? Can they use the ones that are already there?
I've also seen on the boards where I'll then have to do something at the dealer (Infiniti...or can Nissan do it??) regarding re-registration of the TPMS. Didn't realize this until today either.
Also, not sure what I'd do with the Dunlop's, maybe sell them?? Wish someplace would give me a credit toward my new tire purchase if I gave them the Dunlops. I would also assume that the Michelin and Goodyear tires (90,000 and 80,000 treadlife, respectively) would still be in fine shape at the end of my 39 month lease and I'd turn the car in with them on. I'm not a hard core driver, don't squeal the tires or do burnouts.
Any thoughts are greatly appreciated.
My assumption is that either tire would be an ok choice. But I thought maybe some of you may have input on which one would be a better tire, especially for wet and snow traction.
Also, when I go through the motions for purchase on a website, it recommends a TPMS Rebuild Kit. Is this necessary since the car is brand new? Can they use the ones that are already there?
I've also seen on the boards where I'll then have to do something at the dealer (Infiniti...or can Nissan do it??) regarding re-registration of the TPMS. Didn't realize this until today either.
Also, not sure what I'd do with the Dunlop's, maybe sell them?? Wish someplace would give me a credit toward my new tire purchase if I gave them the Dunlops. I would also assume that the Michelin and Goodyear tires (90,000 and 80,000 treadlife, respectively) would still be in fine shape at the end of my 39 month lease and I'd turn the car in with them on. I'm not a hard core driver, don't squeal the tires or do burnouts.
Any thoughts are greatly appreciated.
Spend the money on an extra set of tires, and enjoy the car the way it was meant to perform from the factory! Remember, All-season tires are, by definition, a compromise.
The factory TPMS doesn't need to be altered in any way if you keep the rims on the car, and only swap the tires.
#7
Registered User
iTrader: (1)
Tire & Wheel Noob here:
Would 17-inch rims for snow tires fit on the G37s sedan? I seem to recall reading somewhere the brakes were a bit larger on the sport. Also, what is the complete size of the tires that would go on 17s? Would it still need to be staggered?
Thanks
Would 17-inch rims for snow tires fit on the G37s sedan? I seem to recall reading somewhere the brakes were a bit larger on the sport. Also, what is the complete size of the tires that would go on 17s? Would it still need to be staggered?
Thanks
Trending Topics
#8
Registered User
But I wasn't aware that some of the 18s wouldn't even fit. I guess this is going to take some more research...
#9
Registered User
If the car comes with the big 4 piston calipers with the 14inch disc ( same as the ones on the c37s coupe and has "infiniti" written on them) Then you will need to run at least 18 inch wheels. Also, If u want to get aftermarket wheels you will need to be really careful about the caliper clearance. So to answer your question: If u have the S with the big brakes the best is to get OEM size snow tires and mount and the oem wheels. It does not matter it is not stagger or not as long as it fits properly. IF u dont have big calipers, then you run 17 inchs with offset in the mid to high 40s and 225/55/17 snow tires.
Yeah, it's the 2009 "S" sedan with the big brakes, and 18" OEM wheels. I'd just assumed any 18s would fit, so thanks to everyone for that info.
The problem with getting winter tires mounted on the oem wheels is having to pay twice a year to keep getting them changed. But who knows, maybe that still comes out better than buying a second set of rims. I'll check around.
Thread
Thread Starter
Forum
Replies
Last Post
footballmania32
Private Classifieds
0
09-04-2015 03:06 PM